Who Goes There? and Two versions of The Thing

At our December 6 2008 we watched both The Thing From Another World [1951] and The Thing [1982], following which we discussed both films and the John W. Campbell short story "Who Goes There?" that served as the inspiration for both films.

If you're a Star Base Andromeda member who has read this story and/or seen either of these films, and would like to offer up your opinion, please share your thoughts here with the rest of SBA and anyone else who drops in. As part of your comments, please give "Who Goes There?" a score, from 1 to 10 (10 best) and identify yourself in your comments.

If you're one of those visitors who just stumbled across us, you're welcome to share your opinion here, too.

Thank you for participating!